USA Powerlifting Settles Discrimination Case on Sex-Based Categories
USA Powerlifting has reached a settlement with trans-identifying male powerlifter JayCee Cooper, effectively ending a legal battle that has extended over six years. The organization, however, has made it clear that it will not alter its policy regarding sex-based competition categories. This settlement comes in the wake of a ruling by the Minnesota Supreme Court, which found that USA Powerlifting had discriminated against Cooper under the state's Human Rights Act. The court's decision allowed the organization to argue that its policy was justified under a legitimate business purpose defense, but rather than pursue further legal action, USA Powerlifting opted for a resolution.
Larry Maile, the former president of USA Powerlifting and national women's powerlifting coach, stated, "We continue to believe strongly in the merits of our case, which are supported by global competition standards and bipartisan public sentiment. However, left with few legal options, settlement is in the best interests of the organization." USA Powerlifting has consistently maintained that its policy is based on biological realities rather than gender identity, arguing that men generally possess a strength advantage over women.
For the Training Room
Sponsor press complete.
Research on Strength Disparities in Powerlifting
Research cited during the case supports the claim that biological males retain a significant strength advantage, even after testosterone suppression. This point is critical in a sport where performance is measured by weight lifted. To address inclusion, USA Powerlifting established an "MX Division" in 2021 for transgender and nonbinary athletes while maintaining separate male and female categories.
Improve your workout
The timing of the settlement is significant as international governing bodies increasingly adopt sex-based standards in sports. For instance, the International Olympic Committee has recently implemented a sex testing policy to prevent trans-identifying males from competing in women's events. USA Powerlifting expressed concern that the Minnesota Supreme Court's ruling places the state at odds with national and international sports standards. Maile remarked, "What the plaintiffs cast as a victory for transgender rights is a ruling that has forced Minnesota to take a step backward for women, fair competition, and common sense."
One of the pivotal aspects of this case for USA Powerlifting was the opportunity to present its arguments to a jury. The organization indicated that Cooper's legal team had decided to drop a claim that would have allowed for this, effectively closing the door on a long-sought opportunity. USA Powerlifting has not yet determined its next steps in Minnesota following this ruling and settlement, but it plans to review its options in the coming weeks. Despite the legal outcome, the organization remains steadfast in its belief that the issue of sex-based competition is far from resolved. Maile emphasized, "The fact remains that Minnesota is increasingly out of step with unrefuted science showing a 64% strength advantage for male-born athletes." USA Powerlifting's position continues to be that maintaining categories based on sex is crucial for fairness in the sport of powerlifting.





